REPRESENTATION
Results You Need.
If you receive a court hearing notice for a probation violation, you should immediately obtain a lawyer with the experience and ability to properly defend your probation violation, such as attorney Daniel Hilf. A probation violation (also known as a violation of probation or VOP), places you at the mercy of your Judge when it comes to imposing a sentence. Some Judges give breaks and provide second chances depending upon the reason for the violation. Other Judges are more inclined to order jail or prison, because they feel that probation is a waste of time if you cannot comply with the probationary sentence. The defense or mitigation your attorney performs may prove being the difference between a second chance and being incarcerated. If your case is from Waterford Michigan, and you are on probation with a Judge from the 51st District Court in Waterford or the 6th Circuit Court for Oakland County, these Judges are sometimes strict in the manner they treat probation violations.
When it comes to probation violations, there are different possible outcomes from your Judge:
Your first step for a probation violation is to wisely choose your lawyer. Procedurally, with every probation violation allegation there is an arraignment that occurs at the first court date, where the Judge has the option of setting a bond amount. Even though you are presumed innocent, the Judge can choose to have you incarcerated during the probation violation proceedings if he or she feels that you are a flight risk or a danger to the community.
Once you have a lawyer in place, you will have to make a decision with your lawyer’s help about how you want to proceed. There are only two possible choices: have a hearing to fight the probation violation or plead guilty to the VOP charges. If you hired the right lawyer, you will receive options as to best defending the accusation, and steps that you can take to help you improve your chances if you are convicted after a hearing or by plea. Your VOP attorney ask for an adjournment or delay for a number of reasons including: need to subpoena witnesses; need for additional preparation; desire to consult with an expert witness; scheduling issues; waiting the outcome of a pending criminal matter. It is up to the Judge to decide, after listening to your lawyer, if the request to adjourn the proceedings is granted or denied.
In all Michigan courtrooms, you have due process rights to make sure the violation of probation is handled in a fair manner that comports with due process of law:
The above listed rights only have worth if you have professional, effective legal counsel. Representing yourself is the worst option, because only a skilled VOP attorney has the proper legal acumen, courtroom experience, and emotional detachment to present your case in the best possible light.
If you have a new criminal charge the you believe will be dismissed, you still need an outstanding lawyer for your probation violation. Even with a dismissal, the prosecution still can proceed against you, because the prosecutor’s burden of proof for a probation violation (preponderance of the evidence) is significantly less than the burden of proof for a criminal charge (beyond a reasonable doubt). The rules of evidence do not even apply in the same manner at a probation violation hearing (for example, hearsay evidence is allowed), which also can make the prosecutor’s job much easier. Another problem is that the behavior that allegedly lead to the arrest might still be an issue that needs to be addressed. For example, if a probationer’s dismissed criminal charge was for DUI, the probation violation may be based on having a positive PBT reading for alcohol when stopped.
If the probation violation is based upon unpaid restitution, poverty is not always a defense. In order to place the probationer in custody and/or revoke probation the Court needs to make a determination that the probationer failed to make a good faith effort to pay the money owed, and that the probationer had the ability to pay without suffering a “manifest hardship”. There is no precise legal definition for what constitutes a “manifest hardship” in Michigan and Judges are given a list of factors to weigh and consider to decide if it exists. The factors are: whether or not the probationer is employable; what financial resources (if any) the probationer has; what are the probationer’s living expenses (clothing, food, shelter, child support, medical expenses, etc.); what the probationer has the realistic ability to earn; if the probationer currently has a job; the probationer’s complete employment history; whether or not the failure to pay was on purpose; the existence of any other special circumstances that are relevant to the Judge’s determination.
Some probation violation defenses are built on the testimony of an expert witness. An expert witness is a person with qualifications to give an opinion in a particular field (such as chemistry, engineering, medicine, etc.) based upon special knowledge they have that may assist the Judge. For example, if the probationer tested positive for alcohol and swears up and down that he did not drink any alcohol, an expert witnesses in certain situations may conclude that the likely positive test was due to faulty or contaminated testing procedures. Needless to say, a person without a lawyer would not have the ability to offer the Court expert witness testimony in a meaningful way.
If convicted of the VOP, the Court is required to give you and your lawyer a chance to speak before imposing sentence. If you retain a knowledgable VOP lawyer, that lawyer will give you precise advice as to what to do and what to say (or what not to say) to help increase your chance of a lenient sentence.
Do not hire a lawyer who cannot provide you with a clear course of action, or who does not take time to answer your questions or to plan your defense. Having a top quality VOP lawyer means everything when it comes to your stressful VOP situation. When you need an outstanding VOP lawyer in Oakland County, contact us immediately for help.